网易首页 > 网易号 > 正文 申请入驻

TED学院 | 为什么永动机是行不通的?

0
分享至

英语专业八级考试(TEM-8)的选材主要来自英美报刊杂志、广播电台或网站。其中一个包括:TED演讲,2018和2016年专八听力讲座(Mini-lecture)就来自TED演讲。建议大家平时多看多听TED演讲。





演讲者:Netta Schramm

演讲题目:Why don't perpetual motion machines ever work?

Around 1159 A.D., a mathematician called Bhaskara the Learned sketched a design for a wheel containing curved reservoirs of mercury. He reasoned that as the wheels spun, the mercury would flow to the bottom of each reservoir, leaving one side of the wheel perpetually heavier than the other. The imbalance would keep the wheel turning forever.

大约公元1159年的时候,有一位叫做婆什迦罗智者的数学家,构想出了一种带有很多弯形水银蓄池的轮子。他觉得随着轮子的转动,每个池子里的水银会流到池底,导致轮子的一端总是比另一端更重一点,这种力矩的不平衡会让轮子永远地转下去。

Bhaskara's drawing was one of the earliest designs for a perpetual motion machine, a device that can do work indefinitely without any external energy source. Imagine a windmill that produced the breeze it needed to keep rotating. Or a lightbulb whose glow provided its own electricity.

婆什迦罗的设想是最早期的永动机构想之一,一种不依赖外界能量来源 而能永远工作下去的机器。想象一个可以不断鼓出吹动自己的风的风车。或者一个可以为自己供电的灯泡。

These devices have captured many inventors' imaginations because they could transform our relationship with energy. For example, if you could build a perpetual motion machine that included humans as part of its perfectly efficient system, it could sustain life indefinitely.

这些机器绞尽了许许多多发明家的脑汁,因为它们可以改变我们和能量间的关系。比如说,如果我们能造出一个永动机,它的永动系统包含了人类,那永生就不再是梦了。

There's just one problem. They don't work. Ideas for perpetual motion machines all violate one or more fundamental laws of thermodynamics, the branch of physics that describes the relationship between different forms of energy.

但只有一个问题,永动机是不可能的。所有有关永动机的想法都违背了至少一个热力学基本定律,热力学是描述不同形式能量之间关系的物理学分支。

The first law of thermodynamics says that energy can't be created or destroyed. You can't get out more energy than you put in. That rules out a useful perpetual motion machine right away because a machine could only ever produce as much energy as it consumed.

热力学第一定律是,能量不会凭空产生或消失,你不可能从机器里得到比你放进去更多的能量。这就排除了任何可行的的永动机的可能,因为一台机器最多只能产生和它消耗的同样多的能量。

There wouldn't be any left over to power a car or charge a phone. But what if you just wanted the machine to keep itself moving? Inventors have proposed plenty of ideas. Several of these have been variations on Bhaskara's over-balanced wheel with rolling balls or weights on swinging arms.

不可能还有多余的能量用来驱动车或者给手机充电。但是如果你只是想让机器自己不停地运行下去呢?发明家们想出了很多点子。有一些就是婆什迦罗非平衡轮的变型,比如有着滚动的小球或者是悬挂着重物的杆子。

None of them work. The moving parts that make one side of the wheel heavier also shift its center of mass downward below the axle. With a low center of mass, the wheel just swings back and forth like a pendulum, then stops. What about a different approach?

但是没一种有用。移动的部分确实让轮子的一端更重一些,但同时降低了轮子整体的重心到轮轴以下。在低重心下,轮子只会像钟摆一样前后摆动,最终停下来。换一种思路呢?

In the 17th century, Robert Boyle came up with an idea for a self-watering pot. He theorized that capillary action, the attraction between liquids and surfaces that pulls water through thin tubes, might keep the water cycling around the bowl.

在17世纪,罗伯特·波义尔想出了个点子,一种自己给自己浇水的壶。他理论上证明了毛细作用,一种液体和容器表面间的吸引力足以使水吸进毛细管,这样也许能使水不断的围绕壶循环。

But if the capillary action is strong enough to overcome gravity and draw the water up, it would also prevent it from falling back into the bowl.

但是如果毛细作用大到足以克服重力并可以把水从管中提上来,那毛细作用也应该会阻止水再掉回到壶中。

Then there are versions with magnets, like this set of ramps. The ball is supposed to be pulled upwards by the magnet at the top, fall back down through the hole, and repeat the cycle. This one fails because like the self-watering pot, the magnet would simply hold the ball at the top.

再后来,又有了一些和磁铁有关的永动机设想,比如这套斜坡装置。小球应该会被顶端的磁铁吸引上斜坡,然后从洞中掉回底部,循环往复。这个装置也没能成功,就像之前所说的能给自己浇水的水壶,磁铁只可能把小球吸在顶部不动。

Even if it somehow did keep moving, the magnet's strength would degrade over time and eventually stop working. For each of these machines to keep moving, they'd have to create some extra energy to nudge the system past its stopping point, breaking the first law of thermodynamics.

即使小球能不断运动,磁铁的磁力也会随着时间流逝而消退,最终停止运行。对于所有的这些机器,如果想要保持运动它们必然需要产生一些额外的能量将整个系统推过停止点,这就违反了热力学第一定律。

There are ones that seem to keep going, but in reality, they invariably turn out to be drawing energy from some external source. Even if engineers could somehow design a machine that didn't violate the first law of thermodynamics, it still wouldn't work in the real world because of the second law.

有一些永动机看上去会一直运行下去,但事实上,它们总归会从外界获取额外的能量。即使工程师们能够以某种方式造出了不违反第一定律的永动机,由于第二定律它仍旧不可能实现。

The second law of thermodynamics tells us that energy tends to spread out through processes like friction. Any real machine would have moving parts or interactions with air or liquid molecules that would generate tiny amounts of friction and heat, even in a vacuum.

热力学第二定律告诉我们,能量总是通过某些方式趋于散失,比如摩擦。任何现实生活中的机器都有着移动的部件或者是与气体及液体分子的互相作用,这就会产生微量的摩擦与热量,在真空中也不例外。

That heat is energy escaping, and it would keep leeching out, reducing the energy available to move the system itself until the machine inevitably stopped. So far, these two laws of thermodynamics have stymied every idea for perpetual motion and the dreams of perfectly efficient energy generation they imply.

那些热量就是能量损失,并且它一直在流失,不断地减少可供系统自身运动的能量 直到机器不可避免地停下来。到目前为止,这两条热力学定律已经排除了任何关于永动机的设想以及100%效率产能的可能。

Yet it's hard to conclusively say we'll never discover a perpetual motion machine because there's still so much we don't understand about the universe. Perhaps we'll find new exotic forms of matter that'll force us to revisit the laws of thermodynamics.

但是,这并不能绝对地说我们将永远无法找到永动机,因为我们对整个宇宙的了解还是太少了。也许我们将找到一种新的奇异的物质存在形式,让我们不得不重新审视热力学的定律。

Or maybe there's perpetual motion on tiny quantum scales. What we can be reasonably sure about is that we'll never stop looking. For now, the one thing that seems truly perpetual is our search.

又或许在极小的量子尺度会有永动机的存在。我们能确定的是我们永远不会停止寻找。现在,唯一看上去“永动”的,是我们的搜寻。

【 特别 声明 】 本公众平台除特别注明原创或授权转载外,其他文章均为转载,版权 归原作者或平台所有,出于传递信息之目的,并没有任何商业目的。 本公号尊重知识产权,如无意中侵犯了您的权益,请及时联系后台,本公号将及时删除。

TED学院合集



1










2











3










  • 4











  • 5











  • 6











  • 7










  • 8











  • 9











  • 10











  • 11











  • 12











  • 13











  • 14











  • 15











  • 16




特别声明:以上内容(如有图片或视频亦包括在内)为自媒体平台“网易号”用户上传并发布,本平台仅提供信息存储服务。

Notice: The content above (including the pictures and videos if any) is uploaded and posted by a user of NetEase Hao, which is a social media platform and only provides information storage services.

相关推荐
热点推荐
资本全跑了,演员排队找工作,中国电影怎么就走到这步了?

资本全跑了,演员排队找工作,中国电影怎么就走到这步了?

情感大头说说
2026-06-26 10:27:45
委内瑞拉地震中国公民遇难人数升至8人;强震已致当地1430人死亡,3238人受伤;676万人生存或受影响

委内瑞拉地震中国公民遇难人数升至8人;强震已致当地1430人死亡,3238人受伤;676万人生存或受影响

极目新闻
2026-06-28 07:26:55
打破心魔!劳塔罗9次在世界杯出场终于收获首粒进球

打破心魔!劳塔罗9次在世界杯出场终于收获首粒进球

画夕
2026-06-28 10:58:02
AI PCB涨价潮来了:覆铜板+铜箔+钻针+PCB材料,最受益的公司

AI PCB涨价潮来了:覆铜板+铜箔+钻针+PCB材料,最受益的公司

坠入二次元的海洋
2026-06-28 00:05:07
绿洲珠宝行血案,浙江6任厅长追凶22年,抓到嫌犯后大家都愣住了

绿洲珠宝行血案,浙江6任厅长追凶22年,抓到嫌犯后大家都愣住了

崖边行
2025-06-27 21:11:22
36岁男篮名宿:娶1米83美女,儿女双全,退役后当老板已财富自由

36岁男篮名宿:娶1米83美女,儿女双全,退役后当老板已财富自由

白面书誏
2026-06-25 15:16:22
从分组上上签到看人脸色,韩国队不是太惨了,而是因其太"馋”了

从分组上上签到看人脸色,韩国队不是太惨了,而是因其太"馋”了

英雄稚气
2026-06-27 11:46:32
深圳市一栋4层高的竹筒楼拍卖,被人235.62万元买下了

深圳市一栋4层高的竹筒楼拍卖,被人235.62万元买下了

林子说事
2026-06-27 20:37:38
葡萄牙落位上半区!八强无缘战阿根廷,想看梅罗对决只能期待决赛

葡萄牙落位上半区!八强无缘战阿根廷,想看梅罗对决只能期待决赛

全景体育V
2026-06-28 09:58:11
为什么高考本科线只有400多分,却有一大半学生根本考不上本科?

为什么高考本科线只有400多分,却有一大半学生根本考不上本科?

娱乐的宅急便
2026-06-28 08:40:23
乌克兰加大袭击,克里米亚宣布进入“紧急状态”

乌克兰加大袭击,克里米亚宣布进入“紧急状态”

参考消息
2026-06-27 12:22:52
梅西背后的女人,和C罗背后的女人们,这一对比差距就出来了

梅西背后的女人,和C罗背后的女人们,这一对比差距就出来了

阿废冷眼观察所
2026-06-28 08:17:56
700分以上,浙江断层领先!2026年全国一卷省份高分对比

700分以上,浙江断层领先!2026年全国一卷省份高分对比

史海流年号
2026-06-26 08:07:47
火车霸座咬人风波升级!大妈踢到铁板,受害者发声,估计要赔大了

火车霸座咬人风波升级!大妈踢到铁板,受害者发声,估计要赔大了

音乐时光的娱乐
2026-06-27 16:56:39
韩红被质疑“走到哪,哪就是她的老家”,央媒报道显示,其生于西藏昌都,两岁时前往成都,后定居北京,祖籍山东德州,并非在西藏长大

韩红被质疑“走到哪,哪就是她的老家”,央媒报道显示,其生于西藏昌都,两岁时前往成都,后定居北京,祖籍山东德州,并非在西藏长大

大风新闻
2026-06-25 14:15:08
国际金价、银价,上涨!

国际金价、银价,上涨!

大象新闻
2026-06-27 16:34:08
当场锁喉!想砸全WNBA的饭碗,当然要被禁赛!

当场锁喉!想砸全WNBA的饭碗,当然要被禁赛!

德译洋洋
2026-06-27 12:40:29
震惊了!坐飞机,发现了一名超像豆包的空姐

震惊了!坐飞机,发现了一名超像豆包的空姐

微微热评
2026-06-25 12:35:51
俄军新出炉的反星链系统美方很认可,1个月就被乌军打得干干净净

俄军新出炉的反星链系统美方很认可,1个月就被乌军打得干干净净

赫埰足球解说
2026-06-27 20:39:56
从伪九号到全能后腰:贝林厄姆世界杯大爆发,穆帅的皇马拼图终现

从伪九号到全能后腰:贝林厄姆世界杯大爆发,穆帅的皇马拼图终现

穆里尼奥主义者
2026-06-28 09:20:53
2026-06-28 11:39:00
英语教学 incentive-icons
英语教学
英语学习,读书进步!
21388文章数 100827关注度
往期回顾 全部

教育要闻

多少分能上湖北城市建设职业技术学院?答案揭晓!

头条要闻

割牛草女孩代表北大回母校招生 曾称自己终于走出大山

头条要闻

割牛草女孩代表北大回母校招生 曾称自己终于走出大山

体育要闻

世界杯最火门将,站到了阿根廷和梅西面前

娱乐要闻

白玉兰奖落幕,唯她被骂惨

财经要闻

两只股票撑起的韩国股市,半年熔断 33 次

科技要闻

DeepSeek最新论文:如何让大模型跑得更快

汽车要闻

潮流+复古+科技满配 神行者8带来了豪华新能源的新解法

态度原创

旅游
教育
亲子
时尚
军事航空

旅游要闻

郑州上榜2026暑运铁路出行热门目的地TOP10

教育要闻

高中地理|奇特的地貌——高山流石滩

亲子要闻

胡图图妥妥的是爷爷奶奶们的梦中情孙 杨雪呀

今年夏天被“这件单品”刷屏,时髦又气质!

军事要闻

黎以美达成三方框架协议

无障碍浏览 进入关怀版